UN Struggles to Choose Successor to Guterres after Ninth Vote
UN Still Without Successor to Guterres; Ninth Vote Fails to Yield Agreement
The United Nations has yet to determine who will lead it from January 2027 onward. The UN Security Council failed to agree on a candidate to replace current Secretary-General António Guterres in its ninth preliminary vote. Eight candidates are vying for the position, but none have secured the necessary support so far.
The results of the vote held on Friday, November 20, were announced by U.S. Ambassador to the UN Mike Waltz. The closed-door session took place in New York. According to Waltz, no candidate has yet received enough Security Council backing to be recommended as a consensus choice.
Despite this stalemate, the American diplomat expressed optimism, anticipating that member states might reach an agreement as early as December.
Guterres’ Term Ends in December
Current UN Secretary-General António Guterres’ second term concludes on December 31, 2026. The new head of the organization is expected to assume office at the start of January.
With the successor selection still unresolved, there is a risk the UN could begin the new year without a duly appointed Secretary-General — an extremely unusual situation occurring amid several international crises, armed conflicts, and tensions among great powers.
Choosing the next Secretary-General is not a mere formality. The position represents the UN externally, manages its Secretariat, and plays a crucial role in diplomatic negotiations and resolving international conflicts.
Great Powers with Veto Hold Decisive Influence
To be elected, a candidate must win the support of at least nine of the fifteen UN Security Council members and must not be vetoed by any of the five permanent members.
The United States, Russia, China, France, and the United Kingdom hold veto power. Their positions are pivotal: a candidate may have majority backing but can be blocked by a veto from any single permanent member.
Informal votes serve to gauge support for candidates, with members indicating whether they recommend, do not recommend, or remain neutral toward each candidate. Although these results are not officially published, information often leaks through diplomatic channels.
Eight Candidates Compete for the Top UN Post
The field includes diplomats, former government officials, and individuals with extensive experience in international organizations.
Notable candidates include Costa Rican Rebeca Grynspan, head of the UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), and Rafael Grossi of Argentina, Director General of the International Atomic Energy Agency.
Others vying for the role are Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett from Guyana, Lana Nusseibeh of the United Arab Emirates, María Fernanda Espinosa and Ivonne Baki from Ecuador, Olara Otunnu of Uganda, and Feridun Hadi Sinirlioğlu of Turkey.
The selection process has also sparked discussions about the historic possibility that the UN could, for the first time, be led by a woman.
Earlier coverage on the leadership contest is available in our article “Costa Rican Diplomat Leads Race for UN Secretary-General. Great Powers Will Decide.”
Candidates Court the Support of Five Permanent Members
In recent months, candidates have focused their campaigns primarily on diplomatic negotiations with the countries holding veto rights. Without their consent, a candidate cannot secure a successful recommendation to the UN General Assembly.
While informal votes indicate which candidates have broader support, they do not necessarily predict the final outcome. What matters is whether any candidate can obtain acceptable backing from all five permanent members.
Moreover, the voting itself is not the final appointment: the Security Council must first recommend a candidate, and the appointment is then confirmed by the UN General Assembly.
December Could Be the Deciding Month
The ninth unsuccessful vote increases the time pressure on member states. With only a few weeks left until Guterres’ term expires, diplomatic negotiations must soon produce results.
Despite the deadlock, U.S. Ambassador Mike Waltz expects an agreement could be reached in December. However, it remains uncertain whether the great powers will agree on one of the eight candidates or if a new name will have to be considered.
This is a critical test for the UN’s ability to compromise at a time when tensions between the world’s most powerful nations are high. The new Secretary-General will assume office during a period marked by multiple wars, humanitarian crises, and disputes regarding the organization’s future role.
READ ALSO
- Costa Rican Diplomat Leads Race for UN Secretary-General; Great Powers Will Decide
- Historic Ruling in The Hague: Myanmar Committed Genocide Against Rohingya, Court Rules
- Kyiv Plans to Host UN-Sponsored Peace Summit by End of February
This article was translated from the original Slovak version with the assistance of AI.