European Court Orders Immediate Release of Turkish Opposition MP Can Atalay
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has ruled that Turkey must immediately release opposition lawmaker Can Atalay and allow him to carry out his parliamentary mandate. The judges concluded that his continued detention after being elected to parliament violated several fundamental rights. They also stated that the Turkish authorities’ actions aimed to silence a political opponent and restrict pluralism in the country.
European Court Orders Immediate Release of Lawmaker
On Tuesday, November 17, the ECHR issued its judgment in the case of Turkish lawyer and politician Can Atalay. According to the ruling, Ankara must take all necessary measures to end his detention, secure his immediate release, and enable his return to parliament.
The court also ordered Turkey to pay Atalay €32,500 in damages for non-pecuniary harm.
The judges found breaches of the right to liberty and security, the right to review the legality of detention, and the right to free elections. Most gravely, they noted that the restriction of Atalay’s rights pursued an illegitimate political objective.
According to the court, the lawmaker’s ongoing detention was intended to silence him and suppress political pluralism.
Atalay Elected to Parliament but Remained Imprisoned
Can Atalay is a lawyer and human rights defender who became publicly known for his involvement in the 2013 Gezi Park protests in Istanbul.
In April 2022, a Turkish court sentenced him to 18 years in prison for allegedly aiding an attempt to overthrow the government. Atalay denies the charges, and his case has been the subject of prolonged disputes within Turkey’s judicial system.
In the May 2023 parliamentary elections, voters in Hatay province elected Atalay as a member of parliament for the Workers’ Party of Turkey (TİP). Despite winning the mandate, he remained imprisoned.
Atalay appealed based on parliamentary immunity, requesting release so he could perform his duties. The Turkish Constitutional Court repeatedly ruled in his favor, declaring his continued detention after election a violation of his rights.
Turkish Courts Ignored Constitutional Court Decisions
A key issue arose when the Court of Cassation refused to enforce rulings of the Turkish Constitutional Court.
In October 2023, the Constitutional Court found a violation of Atalay’s right to liberty and political participation. It later issued a further ruling condemning the disregard of its previous judgment.
Nevertheless, the Court of Cassation persisted in its refusal. In January 2024, Atalay’s parliamentary mandate was revoked after a parliamentary announcement confirmed his conviction.
The Constitutional Court subsequently declared the revocation legally invalid. However, this decision was also not enforced.
In its new judgment, the ECHR emphasized that decisions of the Constitutional Court are binding and must be respected by domestic authorities. Ignoring them undermines the rule of law and weakens protection of fundamental rights, the judges stated.
ECHR Highlights Attempt to Silence Political Opponent
The most significant part of the ruling concerns Article 18 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits using restrictions on rights for purposes other than those originally intended.
The judges concluded that keeping Atalay in detention without recognizing his parliamentary immunity also pursued a political objective – to silence him and suppress political pluralism.
The court added that such a practice has a deterrent effect on other human rights defenders engaged in public life.
The ECHR also noted the broader context of the case, stating it was not an isolated event but part of a situation where disregard of Constitutional Court rulings coincided with restrictions on an elected representative’s parliamentary functions.
Importantly, the court did not assess the legality of Atalay’s original 2022 conviction. Instead, it focused on his continued detention after election and the failure to comply with Constitutional Court decisions.
Judgment Not Yet Final
The decision was made by a seven-member chamber of the ECHR’s second section but is not yet final.
Both Turkey and Atalay may request referral to the court’s Grand Chamber within three months. The Grand Chamber may then review the case and issue a final ruling.
This means Turkish authorities face another legal and political challenge. If the ruling becomes final, Turkey will have to implement individual measures concerning Atalay’s release and take steps to ensure respect for Constitutional Court decisions in the future.
The case again raises questions about judicial independence, opposition protection, and human rights adherence in Turkey.
READ ALSO
- European Parliament warns democracy in Turkey is weakening, calls for tougher measures
- Turkish courts detain 62 LGBTQ+ activists and supporters
- Turkish court releases investigative journalist but bars leaving the country
This article was translated from the original Slovak version with the assistance of AI.